 |
Hand Call Schemes
Emergency hand call
is a perpetually thorny issue, because hand call can be fairly demanding,
and because it is common for surgeons who would not consider themselves
qualified to take emergency hand call to nonetheless perform elective hand
surgery. Generally, the pool of those taking call is taken from both orthopaedic
and plastic surgeons. There are many existing schemes, and many hospitals
rotate between different solutions depending on the exact numbers of those
available and willing to take call. Here are common setups I have seen:
| Type |
No formal call schedule |
| Description |
Coverage determined on the
fly by the emergency room doctor |
| Advantages |
No maintenance |
| Disadvantages |
Unpredictable. May not be able
to provide coverage. Emergency room may be told by all potential surgeons
that they are not available or that the problem is out of their level of
expertise. Hand specialists in the area wind up being on 24/7/365 "backup"
call. |
| Type |
Dealer's Choice |
| Description |
Hand cover is provided either
by the person on call for orthopaedics or by the person on call for plastics,
to be determined by the emergency room physician as to whether the problem
is more "bone" or "soft tissue". |
| Advantages |
In theory, provides full cover.
Spreads the burden of call the most widely. Typically used when no smaller
group wishes to claim all call, and there is no organized refusal to take
hand call. |
| Disadvantages |
1. Unpredictable. May not be
able to provide coverage. Emergency room may be told by both ortho and
plastic surgeons that the problem, such as a mangled hand, is out of their
specialty.
2. May not provide consistent
community standard of care, especially if certified hand surgery specialists
take some of the call.
3. Inequities: Orthopods get
all the closed fractures; Plastics get all the tendon injuries and all
infections. |
| Type |
Alternate Night |
| Description |
Hand cover is provided either
by the person on call for orthopaedics or by the person on call for plastics,
to be determined by the date, day of the week or similar - for example,
odd days: hand goes to Orthopaedics, even days: hand goes to Plastics. |
| Advantages |
In theory, provides full cover.
Spreads the burden of call the most widely. Typically used when no smaller
group wishes to claim all call, and there is no organized refusal to take
hand call. |
| Disadvantages |
May not provide consistent
community standard of care, especially if certified hand surgery specialists
take some of the call. |
| Type |
Dedicated: Softball |
| Description |
Hand cover is provided by a
group of surgeons who specialize in hand, take all comers, and determine
the call schedule internally. "Hand" is defined as beginning at the distal
forearm, radiocarpal joint, carpus, or carpometacarpal level, depending
on the wishes of the group taking call. Call schedule is not tied
to other triage, such as operating room privileges, elective referrals
by the hospital, triage within an orthopaedic group, etc. |
| Advantages |
In theory, provides the best
qualified cover. Typically used when 3 or more hand specialists are on
staff. Takes hand call burden away from relatively less qualified surgeons. |
| Disadvantages |
Places the full burden of call
on a smaller group of surgeons. Because of frequent nighttime calls, burnout
more likely. Elective hand cases are skimmed by those not taking call,
leaving the more demanding problems for those who do. |
| Type |
Dedicated: Hardball |
| Description |
Hand cover is provided by a
group of surgeons who specialize in hand, take all comers, and determine
the call schedule internally. "Hand" is defined as beginning at the
distal forearm. Those taking all the call also negotiate for exclusive
rights to elective hospital hand referrals and to hand privileges in the
hospital operating room. This includes all hand surgery, including that
for carpal tunnel, trigger finger, deQuervain's, etc. |
| Advantages |
In theory, provides the best
qualified cover, maximizes referral stream. Typically used when 3 or more
hand specialists are on staff. Takes hand call burden away from relatively
less qualified surgeons. |
| Disadvantages |
Places the greatest burden
of call on a smaller group of surgeons. Because of frequent nighttime calls,
burnout more likely. |
 |
American
Society
for
Surgery
of the
Hand
assh.org
The Best
Resource
For Your
Hands,
Period.
|
