 |
COMPLICATIONS IN
HAND SURGERY
INTRODUCTION
Normally, the hand is a transparent
interface, performing voluntary tasks without bringing attention to
itself. Following hand injury, recovery of anything less than this level
of performance is a complication. By this measure, complications of hand
injuries are very common, and the primary goal of the treatment
of hand trauma is simply that of avoiding complications.
Complications in this chapter
are grouped according to whether they are considered to be complications
of missed diagnoses, complications of treatment,
or complications of injuries. Although there is
overlap in these categories, they form a framework for the treating physician
to organize a personal approach to reduce the risk of complications in
hand surgery.
MISSED
DIAGNOSES
Missed
Hand Injuries. The best insurance against missed diagnosis of hand
injuries is an adequate history and physical examination.
History.
Severe upper extremity injuries are frequently dramatic and attended by
emotional factors. Because of this, it is usually best to obtain a history
in a deliberate, orderly way. If possible, after hearing the story, the
examiner should physically demonstrate the scenario of injury back to the
patient to confirm the examiner's understanding of the details, including
the position of the extremity at the time of injury. If an injury involves
machinery, it should be described well enough to be visualized, in simple
mechanical terms: was the mechanism sharp or dull? Did the mechanism involve
rotating blades, belts, or chains? Was there exposure to heat, cold, or
chemicals? Much of the nature of damage and extent of injury can be predicted
before the examination. For example: Did the patient land on their palm
with their wrist extended or on the dorsum of their wrist? Was the patient
able to pull their hand out, or was it trapped, requiring extrication?
Was the bleeding pulsatile? Even in what seems to be an obvious situation,
clarification is important, and one should not assume that all problems
with the hand developed as a consequence of a single reported injury: Did
the pain start immediately after the event, or later? Did the numbness
begin at the time of injury or later? Has the hand been injured previously?
Recently? A long time ago? Before the injury, were there any problem with
numbness, weakness or pain? Shoulder problems? Night time hand numbness?
Attention to such details from the onset can avoid misguided treatment
and false expectations. Additionally, hand injuries are a common starting
point for personal injury litigation, and clear initial documentation of
these points will prevent needless later aggravation at the hands of lawyers.
Examination. A
working knowledge of anatomy usually allows much of the examination for
an acute injury to be performed without touching the obvious site of injury.
Sensory, motor and vascular examination distal to the injury can
provide clues as to the status of more proximal wounds. This gentle approach
is clearly preferable to attempting to define the injury by probing or
instrumenting a wound in the emergency room.
Rapid
survey of the hand. A focused, informative survey of the injured
hand can be performed in about a minute. It is best to proceed with
examination of the injured hand using a systems check list technique:
Objective findings
-
Skin: wounds, texture,
turgor.
-
Vascular: color, temperature,
turgor, capillary refill, pulses.
-
Bone and Joint: deformity,
instability.
-
Muscle and Tendon: posture,
compartment turgor.
Subjective findings
-
Perception of Injury:
pain, tenderness, apprehension of pain, weakness.
-
Peripheral
nerve function: A focused examination of the median, ulnar and radial
nerves can be performed within a few seconds, checking nerve specific sensory
islands and muscles having a unique nerve innervation (survey.htm).
-
Skeleton: tenderness
at the site of injury. Indirect tenderness, or pain with gentle
percussion, traction, torsion, or bending stress applied to the skeleton
at
a distance from the area of injury, will occur when there is pathologic
skeletal micromotion due to fracture or ligament injury.
-
Muscle and tendon:
strength.
Active unresisted motion may be limited,
but even so, when present, can confirm tendons in continuity and intact
innervation of the proximal muscles. regarding tendon and nerve status.
Tips for examining the
hand of an unconscious patient. Objective
examination is obviously limited when with the patient is not fully cooperative,
but much can still be assessed in the absence of subjective findings using
these four categories of assessment:
Vascular:
Color of the skin and nail beds compared to the opposite side can indicate
arterial (pale) or venous (dark or purple) insufficiency. Allen's test
can
be performed without patient participation by gently squeezing the palm
while occluding radial and ulnar arteries at the wrist, then releasing
one artery to assess patency of the two main arteries as well as the palmar
arch. Digital Allen's test is performed in similar fashion, using
the examiner's fingertips to exsanguinate a finger from distal to proximal,
and then releasing one or the other side at the base of the finger (digitalallen.htm).
Forearm
compartment pressures can be measured with commercial kits
or with materials available in any emergency room.
Muscle
and Tendon: Posture
of
the fingers can indicate specific tendon injuries. Even if the patient
is unconscious or under anesthesia, if the tendons and phalanges are intact,
the fingers should assume a cascade position of progressively more
flexion of both proximal and distal interphalangeal joints proceeding from
the index to the small finger (survey.htm,
cuttend.htm).
Tenodesis
motion of the fingers can be used to check relative finger posture during
passive wrist flexion and extension (tenodesis2.htm,
tenodesis4.htm).
Squeezing
the mid forearm will tighten the finger flexor tendons and mimic their
active action.
Bone
and Joint: Rotation of the fingers may be suspected if the tips overlap,
but if the fingertips are not adjacent during flexion, it is normal for
them all to converge toward a common target - the distal pole of the scaphoid,
where the flexor carpi radialis tendon intersects the wrist flexion crease
(point2.htm,
1432000s.htm).
Contour
abnormalities at joints or along long bones may indicate fractures
or dislocations. Common contour changes due to displaced fractures include
those due to distal radius fractures (1493502sx.htm),
metacarpal neck fractures, and proximal phalanx fractures. Metacarpophalangeal
or proximal interphalangeal joint dislocations alter flexor / extensor
tendon tension balance and may present as unusual posture or positioning
of joints distal to the injury (1437308x.htm).
Bruising
at
a site away from an area of impact, such as dorsal wrist
bruising after a fall on the outstretched palm, strongly suggests
an underlying skeletal injury even with normal x-rays. Passive range
of motion of the elbow, wrist and fingers can be used to assess crepitation
(joint surface injury), resistance (swelling, subluxation, dislocation)
and instability (ligament injury).
Nerve:
Because
the digital nerves are superficial to the digital arteries, an abnormal
digital
Allen test (digitalallen.htm)
in the context of any palmar finger laceration strongly suggests an associated
digital
nerve injury, because the zone of external injury must pass through
the nerve before reaching the artery . Tactile adherence is
assessed by sliding an object with a smooth surface across the palmar skin.
Compared to normal skin, a smooth surface such as a glass slide or the
barrel of a shiny smooth plastic pen will slide with much less resistance
("adherence") over skin affected by nerve injury because
recently denervated
skin does not sweat. Normally, microscopic sweat droplets on the palmar
skin confer some palpable resistance to this motion. The wrinkle test
makes use of the finding that recently denervated skin does not
wrinkle with prolonged water contact. In this this test, fingers are
immersed in water (not saline or other salt solution) for five minutes,
the inspected for wrinkling, which indicates denervation if absent (1491801s.htm).
The mechanism of this test is unknown.
Missed problems elsewhere.
A
dramatic hand injury can divert the attention of both the surgeon and the
patient from a standard trauma systems evaluation. Complications from missed
injuries are most likely when a patient has sustained a traumatic amputation
in a blunt trauma scenario, such as a traffic accident or a fall.
Life threatening central nervous system or thoracoabdominal injuries may
be missed, as well as proximal skeletal and brachial plexus injuries. A
common occult medical condition accompanying hand injury is substance abuse:
in one report, nearly half of patients requiring emergency room treatment
for hand trauma tested positive for alcohol or other substance abuse (AA).
COMPLICATIONS
OF TREATMENT
Common complications of
the treatment of hand injuries
The most common complication
of any hand injury is stiffness, due to the collaborative effects of
inflammation,
swelling
and immobility. Attempts at prevention of stiffness are much more
effective and worthwhile than later attempts to correct established stiffness.
This and other complications are less likely when the treatment follows
priority based guidelines.
Priorities:
Management priorities are the same for severe and minor injuries: establish
the extent of injury; remove the bad; reconstruct the good; involve the
patient and tailor the surgery to the patient (CO).
Severe upper extremity injuries with soft tissue loss have shorter hospitalization
and more rapid recovery with primary reconstruction, even if this
requires primary microvascular free flap surgery (DC).
One conceptual approach to organizing the initial management of severe
head injuries is to break down priorities as they relate to either healing
or function:
Healing priorities:
circulation, skeleton, closure: Inadequate blood supply
is the single most likely explanation for complications of delayed healing,
fibrosis and infection. Adequate blood supply is achieved by aggressive
debridement, revascularization, and use of vascularized flaps.
Edema
represents inadequate lymphatic circulation, and has the same ultimate
effects as inadequate blood supply. Edema is best treated with elevation
and active range of motion, when permitted. Optimum bone and
joint reconstruction goals are prompt, anatomic reduction of
injury and stable skeletal fixation with the least amount of additional
soft tissue disruption. Wound closure
with mobile, well vascularized
soft tissue cover should be achieved as quickly as possible. In the
hand, stiffness, difficulty with use and ultimate disability is directly
related to the length of time required for wound healing.
Function priorities:
nerve, joint, muscle: Nerve injuries should be approached aggressively,
as there is never a better time to evaluate and to perform repairs, and
the only satisfactory time to repair partial nerve lacerations is
in the acute setting (prtnerve2.htm,
foreign.htm).
Passive range of motion has two components: The first is preservation
of the
gliding function of the surfaces of the joints and tendons.
This is achieved by early protected motion: all moving parts in
which are safe to move are moved frequently, against no resistance and
at the earliest opportunity. The second is maintenance of physiological
length
of capsuloligamentous and muscular tissues. This is achieved by splinting
the hand in between exercises in the "protective position": interphalangeal
joint extension, metacarpophalangeal joint flexion, and preservation of
the thumb-index web space span (safepose.htm).
Active
range of motion additionally reduces edema, builds strength, promotes
bone healing, prevents dysfunctional patterns of disuse, and probably reduces
the incidence of complex regional pain syndrome.
Complications of bandaging
Tight dressings:
Finger
dressings made from tubular gauze may produce ischemic pressure complications.
Technical errors in application predisposing to tubular gauze pressure
complications include excessive longitudinal traction during application,
using more than a 90 degree twist during application, and rolled proximal
dressing edges (AX). Even minimally
tight elastic dressings applied as part of a circumferential bandage
may lead to progressive swelling, aggravating all of the ill effects of
swelling on the injured hand, as described above. Swelling may hinder
assessment and may delay surgery until reduced by elevation and change
to a noncompressive dressing. Complications of elastic dressings are less
when applied with care, and when applied over a bulky soft non circumferential
bandage. The technical trick is to place a multiple linear circumferential
gauze bandage as the deepest portion of the bandage, then split it longitudinally
before completing the bandage. This ensures that at least the deepest
layer of bandage cannot provide circumferential pressure. Tight casts
may result in local pressure sores, discomfort, and in the worst scenario,
vascular compromise and compartment syndrome. The situation at greatest
risk is circumferential casts applied after closed reduction of an elbow
or forearm fracture on the day of injury. In this situation, the
risk may be reduced by primarily splitting the cast immediately after application.
Inadequate positioning:
Splints
and other supportive dressings maintain a posture which may be helpful
or detrimental. Often, splints fabricated in the emergency room for
comfort maintain joints in positions which promote stiffness.
Even splints intended to maintain the generic "protective position" may
actually do just the opposite, a problem which may only be confirmed by
x-ray (safepose2.htm).
Complications of wound
care:
The goal of wound care is to maintain an environment which discourages
excessive bacterial growth and encourages normal healing. Excessive
bacterial growth occurs on moist undisturbed services, and is a common
problem in the interdigital web spaces of the immobilized hand, and beneath
occlusive bandages. Eventually, unchecked surface growth produces such
high concentrations of organisms that the skin is invaded directly, producing
maceration
dermatitis. This may progress to cellulitis, but in the early
stages can be stopped by increasing frequency addressing changes, and when
possible, allowing be affected skin to dry. Allergic contact dermatitis
may develop over the course of treatment using topical antibiotics or skin
preparation formulas such as Mastisol (dermatitis.htm).
This can produce a confusing picture, for inflammation associated with
the reaction may be confused with infection. The early hallmarks of contact
dermatitis are itching and blistering accompanying the reaction.
Complications of hand
procedures
Tourniquet palsy after
surgery occurs in an average of one in 5000 cases, more commonly associated
with microsurgical than other procedures (AY).
All nerves are usually affected to some degree, the radial nerve usually
worst affected. Tourniquet palsy is more likely in patients with coagulation
disorders, pre-existing neuropathy, thin malnourished patients, those with
systemic lupus erythematosus (AY) and
in instances of unintentionally high tourniquet pressures due to gauge
failure (BM).
Toxic shock syndrome
is a rare complication, but has been reported after elective reconstructive
hand surgery (BI).
Needle stick / vascular
cannulation injuries
Radial artery catheterization
may result in acute hand ischemia if there is inadequate perfusion through
the ulnar artery (BS). This problem is
more
likely when ulnar artery perfusion is not confirmed by Allen's test before
catheterization, when relatively large diameter cannulas (18 gauge versus
20 gauge) are used (BV), during prolonged
periods of cannulation, and in hypercoagulable states (BS).
In the presence of ulnar artery occlusion, even a single radial artery
needle stick for arterial blood gas determination can precipitate acute
hand ischemia (vascular.htm). Although
uncommon, ischemia resulting in finger amputation has been reported after
arterial monitoring in infants (CL).
Cutaneous nerve injury.
The cephalic vein is frequently cannulated for intravenous access.
It is closely related to the antebrachial cutaneous nerve in the proximal
forearm and branches of the superficial radial nerve in the distal forearm.
Although uncommon, needle stick injuries of either of these nerves can
occur (BJ) and lead to prolonged morbidity.
Patients report feeling a strong electrical paresthesia at the time of
injury, which should be taken as a sign of possible injury. Numbness or
tingling lasting more than a day may represent partial nerve injury, and
should lead to consideration of early exploration. Treatment options for
chronic cases are the same as for any cutaneous neuroma, although more
likely to be compounded by the effects of litigation.
Suppurative thrombophlebitis
(see below).
Extravasation injuries
(DY,
DZ,
EA,
EB,
EC,
ED,
EE)
of the hand are common, because of the common use of the hand for intravenous
access. Local tissue necrosis has been reported following subcutaneous
extravasation of chemotherapy, osmotically active substances, and tissue
toxic preparations such as injectable phenytoin. These injuries often have
delayed presentation, delayed healing, and prolonged morbidity, requiring
reconstructive surgery if treated late. Major limb growth disturbances
may occur following extravasation or thrombosis in the neonatal period.
Although not well described in the literature, tense hematomas associated
with intravenous access of the wrist or dorsal hand may also result in
tissue loss (hematoma.htm). Extravasation
injuries have the best potential outcome when recognized and treated early.
Unfortunately, delayed presentation is still common because of the typically
slow development of visible signs of injury. Treatment recommendations
have varied over the years, but early treatment with soft tissue infiltration/irrigation
has the most consistent history of effectiveness. Local injection with
hyaluronidase is helpful, but this drug is no longer available for use.
Prevention appears to be the best approach, by avoiding of the dorsal hand,
anterior wrist, and antecubital fossa, as these locations are most prone
to complications from extravasation.
Prior axillary lymphadenectomy:
Although it is common practice to instruct patients who have undergone
mastectomy and axillary dissection to avoid manipulation or instrumentation
of the hand, there is not a documented increased risk of complications
in this context (DP). Hand surgery on
the side of previous axillary dissection is probably safe.
Complications of anesthesia
Epinephrine in digital
block: Although it is traditional teaching that epinephrine used in
digital nerve blocks may result in digital gangrene, there are no actual
reported cases of finger gangrene resulting specifically from the use of
epinephrine with lidocaine for digital block, and its safe use has been
reported (AN).
Postoperative ulnar nerve
palsy due to ulnar neuropathy at the level of the elbow is a recognized
but poorly understood complication of surgery involving general anesthesia
(AR). The exact mechanism of this process
remains unknown. Preventative measures, including protective positioning
on the operative table, use of elbow pads, avoidance of arm abduction,
pronation and elbow flexion may reduce that has not been shown to prevent
the development of this problem. Final outcome is unpredictable,
and both conservative and operative treatments have yielded mixed results.
Brachial plexus block
anesthesia has been reported to have an incidence of postoperative
dysesthesias ranging from less than two per cent (DT,
DU)
to as high as a twelve per cent (AT,
DQ).
Although rare, perineural fibrosis (DS)
and permanent neurologic injury (AU)
following axillary block anesthesia has also been reported. Complex regional
pain syndrome has been reported to be both more common and less common
after axillary brachial plexus block.
COMPLICATIONS
OF INJURY
General complications
of hand injury
Severe hand injuries
are most often due to crush or rotating blade mechanism, and are best treated
by a hand surgery specialist (CO).
Such injuries usually involve all organ systems of the hand and are always
associated with complications. Treatment principles and initial management
which may be adequate for lesser injuries may be inadequate in the management
of a mangled hand (DI). Intervention
by a specialist reduces the duration and extent of disability as well as
reducing the overall care requirements and cost for care in severe extremity
trauma.
Scar contracture:
Contractures due to skin scarring are more likely to be a problem if scars
extend longitudinally across the flexor surface of a joint. Scar contractures
in severe cases may develop over the first few weeks after injury, but
in many cases progress over the course of months. In the growing
child, scar contractures may lead to progressive growth disturbances. Stiffness
and contractures due to mechanical changes in joints and tendons, as discussed
above, may develop independently.
Cosmetic deformity:
The immature scar may be hypertrophic: thick, red, and raised. These
changes usually resolve gradually over the course of a year, although the
process may take longer in young children. Permanent visible deformity
from hyperpigmentation, thin stretched scars over extensor surfaces, and
tight scar bands across flexor surfaces may all be troublesome. Fingernail
deformities are common after lacerations and crush injuries in the
area of the nailbed. The most common problems are split nail from
nailbed injury and hook nail deformity from loss of the tuft of
the distal phalanx in a fingertip amputation. Such problems are sometimes
unavoidable, but the best prevention is meticulous anatomic repair of nailbed
lacerations. Once established, fingernail deformities may be difficult
or impossible to correct.
Complex regional pain
syndrome: (rsd.htm, tipsrsd.htm)
Complex regional pain syndrome, previously known as reflex sympathetic
dystrophy, algodystrophy, sympathetic maintained pain, Sudeck's atrophy
and other names may develop after any hand injury, particularly when associated
with nerve injury or irritation. This problem may occur spontaneously,
after major or minor injury. It variably involves spontaneous burning pain,
hyperalgesia, swelling, vasomotor disturbances, disuse, and exacerbations
by movement. Although there may be spontaneous resolution, the majority
of patients develop some degree of chronic symptoms such as pain, stiffness,
and difficulty with normal use of the hand despite all available treatment
(EF). Best results of treatment require
early recognition, aggressive medical therapy, and elimination of triggering
phenomena. Medical therapy may involve sympathetic nerve blocks, gabapentin
or other medications, and biofeedback. Triggers known to aggravate
the condition include peripheral nerve irritation from neuroma or compressive
neuropathy, aggressive passive range of motion in therapy, and dynamic
hand splinting. The effects of complex regional pain syndrome may be far
more disabling than the initial injury.
Dysfunctional use:
Patients may develop maladaptive patterns of use after injury, ranging
from awkward positioning to complete disuse of the hand. This is often
due to unconscious reflex protective mechanisms, and may be difficult to
correct. Extensor habitus refers to the
tendency for the injured index finger or small finger to be held in extension.
This unconscious posturing is powered by the independent extensor of the
finger, and is best treated by early recognition and buddy taping. Alien
hand syndrome refers to a complete disuse of the hand accompanied by
a perception by the patient that the hand is "not theirs". Such problems
may also be factitious, but labeling them as such does not improve the
overall outcome.
Compartment syndrome
of the hand may develop after crush injury, reperfusion following fracture
related ischemia, intravenous injections, crush or blast injury (BB),
bleeding following fracture, arterial cannulation or regional surgery,
or due to prolonged pressure on the hand or arm. The forearm is the most
common site for compartment syndrome in the upper extremity. Compartment
syndrome of the upper extremity is more likely to develop in patients who
are obtunded. Seriously ill children who receive multiple venous and arterial
injections are also at particular risk. Treatment requires prompt recognition
and decompression of intrinsic muscle compartments as well as carpal tunnel
released in selected cases (AS). The
late consequence of compartment syndrome of the upper extremity is Volkmann's
contracture (BB,
CS)
which involves both muscle contracture and local ischemic neuropathy. Ischemic
muscle contractures respond poorly to nonoperative measures such as splinting,
and requires an aggressive surgical approach using muscle slides, tendon
lengthening and tendon transfers similar to those used in the treatment
of upper extremity spasticity. Neurolysis is indicated for persistent nerve
symptoms, but outcome is unpredictable.
Complications of specific
injuries
Complications of complex
wounds Complex wounds are wounds which require additional procedures,
such as radical debridement, to achieve wound closure.
Complications of missed
complex wounds
Severe
contamination is a common theme in missed complex wounds of the hand
because the hand is so often physically exposed to contaminated mechanisms
of injury.
Bite injuries
Human bite injuries of
the hand most often take the form of clenched fist bite injuries, sustained
when the hand strikes the mouth of another person in an altercation. The
most common constellation of injuries is a skin laceration at the metacarpal
head level, accompanied by extensor tendon injury and metacarpal head injury.
The pitfall in managing this injury is the fact that the injury is usually
sustained when the hand is in a clenched fist position, but the patient
frequently does not present until the hand is swollen and the metacarpophalangeal
joint is held in extension. This change of position places the soft
tissue and bone injuries at an offset, giving the appearance that the injury
is more superficial than it is (1071401S.htm,
boxer4.htm).
Treatment requires a high level of suspicion and aggressive debridement
and intravenous antibiotics appropriate for a bite injury.
Animal bite injuries of
the hand are most often from dog and cat bites. They can lead to prolonged
morbidity, particularly when there is a delay between injury and initial
treatment (CR). Dog bites are associated
with soft tissue crush injury and fractures. Cat bites are particularly
dangerous in hand because the needle like teeth of the cat can easily penetrate
into joint spaces, tendon sheaths and other deep compartments of the hand
through a relatively innocuous appearing skin wound.
Insect bites of the
hand such as brown recluse spider bites may cause painful, slow healing
wounds with chronic functional deficits. The initial bite injury may be
painless. When surgical excision is indicated, results appear to be better
when surgery is delayed until after the acute inflammatory process has
subsided (EF).
Rattlesnake bite injuries
of the upper extremity have serious complications and at least one
third of cases, including local soft tissue necrosis (most common complication),
coagulopathy, stiffness, loss of sensibility, and Volkmann's contracture
(BT). Antivenin and steroids reduce the
degree of swelling and hemorrhage, but do not affect or prevent tissue
necrosis (snakebite.htm), which may
require operative treatment.
Chemical Burns
Industrial acid burns
of
the hand occur when the inexperienced or careless worker splashes even
small amounts of acid on their fingers or hand. This type of injury
can go undetected on initial evaluation unless a careful history is obtained
because visible signs of injury are often delayed (hfl.htm).
Hydrochloric and hydrofluoric acids are used in industrial processing,
and may cause severe burns which are not manifest for a day after exposure.
Early recognition and treatment with topical, intravenous or intraarterial
calcium gluconate reduce pain and extent of tissue loss.
White phosphorus burns
are
sustained in the handling of military munitions, fireworks, and other industrial
and agricultural products. Deep progressive burns and systemic effects
of multiple organ system failure may result. Although
copper sulfate
has been recommended as a specific antidote, the most safe and effective
treatment is copious water irrigation (EH).
Again, immediate recognition and treatment of the nature of injury is essential
to reduce long term complications.
Injection injuries
High
pressure injection injuries of paint, sand, lubricating fluid and other
materials are uncommon, but important because they are also on the list
of injuries missed in the accident ward. Typically, the patient has briefly
placed their hand or fingertip over a pressure spray nozzle, sustaining
an injection of material into the soft tissues. Under pressure, this material
tracks up tissue planes next to flexor tendons, nerves, arteries and through
the named bursae and compartments of the hand and arm. Debris may be driven
from the fingertip to the chest wall. The examiner may be misled by a small
visible wound and (depending on the material injected) relatively few physical
findings, and the patient may be discharged only to return within 24 hours
because of worsening symptoms. X-rays may show soft tissue air, particulate
debris, or pigment in certain types of paint. Treatment is emergency radical
debridement (CN). The pressure injected
material tends to track through the loose areolar tissue along longitudinal
structures, and only careful debridement may allow preservation of all
vital structures (1491601x.htm). In
contrast, late surgical treatment may require en bloc tumor like
excision of contaminated zones or amputation. Late results are worst when
the injected material is either a petroleum based solvent or particulate
(sandblasting) material, when the tendon sheath is involved, and when there
is wide proximal spread of the injected material (DH).
The injected material is not sterile, and prophylactic antibiotic treatment
is indicated. Pressure injection injuries presenting with poor perfusion
should be treated with primary amputation (DH).
Injection of pressurized aerosol flurocarbon liquids such as used in refrigerants
may additionally result in deep frostbite injury.
Intentional injection
injuries
of household cleaners, solvents, mercury or illicit drugs
may be difficult to sort out because of either delusional or drug seeking
nature of the patient. X-rays may show particulate or metallic debris or
evidence of gas forming infection (ivdagas.htm).
Factitious or intentional
wounds of the hand are uncommon, but very difficult to treat successfully
because of recurrence. Swelling, ulceration, and recurrent
wound breakdown are common themes. Such wounds are most typical on
the dorsum of the nondominant hand. Narcotic seeking behavior may be part
of the overall picture. The most important aspect of treatment is recognition,
so that unnecessary, unsuccessful, or mutilating procedures may be avoided.
Although the problem is psychiatric, psychiatric intervention may or may
not be helpful, and confrontation is generally ineffective intervention.
Such patients may jump from doctor to doctor in a community, and it is
wise to notify local colleagues when such a patient is identified.
Complications of obvious
complex wounds: Complex
wounds are, by definition, prone to complications even with ideal management.
Common complex injuries of the hand have predictable types of complications,
which are listed below.
Traumatic
amputations of the hand most often involve the fingers. The associated
nerve injury always forms a neuroma, and the treating surgeon should
trim the digital nerve ends away from the distal wound to lessen the chance
of disabling scar tenderness. Dysesthesia is common and all patients
should be provided with an early desensitization program that they can
do at home.
Complex regional pain syndrome may be triggered and
then maintained by tender finger amputation stumps (tipsrsd.htm)
and early on may be difficult to distinguish from swelling, stiffness,
tenderness and avoidance always associated with the injury. Cold
sensitivity or intolerance is a problem for the majority of patients,
but usually improves after the first year. When there is loss of more than
the distal third of the distal phalanx, a hook nail deformity will result,
with the fingernail curving toward the palm, covering the distal fingertip.
This and other variations of retained nail remnant may be avoided
by careful total excision of the entire germinal matrix of the time of
amputation closure. Fingertip amputations are no less problematic than
more proximal amputations, particularly when the critical contact areas
used in pinching and fine manipulation are involved (1114301s.htm).
Amputations through the proximal phalanx often result in extensor habitus,
described above. Metacarpophalangeal joint disarticulation
of the index or small finger results in an easily traumatized and visibly
prominent metacarpal head. Metacarpophalangeal joint disarticulation of
the middle or ring finger results in a "hole in the hand", through which
small objects held in the cupped palm can fall. Treatment of either of
these scenarios with removal of a metacarpal replaces the original problem
with a narrowed palm and reduced torque grip strength.
Fingertip
injuries other than amputations still carry all of the painful
and otherwise disabling complications of finger amputations.
Nail deformities, tender scars and nonunion (1121100s.htm)
are all difficult treatment issues. Pediatric fingertip crush injuries
are common, and severe injuries involving a sterile matrix laceration with
a tuft fracture are frequently missed in children (DF).
These injuries require meticulous nailbed repair to avoid deformity.
Foreign bodies in
the hand are most often symptomatic when they involve the distal phalanx
(BK). Removal of foreign bodies which
are lodged entirely beneath the surface should be performed with tourniquet
control and surgical anesthesia. Otherwise, a common result is that
the area of a foreign body is incised, attempts at retrieval unsuccessful,
and the problem is compounded by the inflammation and scarring from instrumentation.
Foreign bodies are most likely to give rise to problems when they are composed
either of organic (wood, plant thorn, etc.) or highly contaminated materials.
Phoenix
date palm thorns frequently produce a chronic sterile inflammatory
reaction and require radical debridement and extensive synovectomy as the
primary treatment (DV). Foreign body
entry points at the dorsal surfaces of the metacarpophalangeal or interphalangeal
joints, or at the palmar flexion increases of the fingers are at particular
risk for contamination of tendons and deep space infections. Chronic symptomatic
foreign body problems require tumor like excision and synovectomy, not
incision and removal (foreign.htm).
Thermal burn injuries
of the upper extremity result in stiffness of the hand, and the best prevention
for this is early active motion within two weeks of injury (CQ).
This goal is difficult to achieve reliably, because depth of burn may be
difficult to assess, and areas which require skin grafting must be immobilized
for at least one week after surgery. When possible, the goal is early
definitive wound closure with full thickness or tangential excision and
skin grafts or flaps, followed by motion at the earliest possible opportunity.
The ultimate disability in hand function is thought to relate to the time
required to achieve wound closure, although this point is controversial
(CY). Burn injuries can cause lifetime
problems which can not be cured with any amount of surgery and therapy,
and the surgeon must strive to promote realistic, achievable goals (CW).
Compartment
syndrome (AS,
BB),
contractures
(CT) of web spaces, extensor and flexor
services, hypertrophic scars and heterotopic ossification
are common complications. Although rare, surface contact burns over the
course of the brachial artery may lead to ischemic limb loss (AD).
Pediatric
burns of the hand more commonly involve an isolated contact burn of
the palm, particularly in infants, sustained when a child grabs a hot object
such as a curling iron, and then grips even more tightly in response to
pain. As for burns in other areas, excision and grafting is indicated if
the injury is expected to take longer than three weeks to heal, but in
this instance, contractures requiring additional reconstructive procedures
are common (CT). Pediatric hand burns
have the most favorable outcome when managed in a specialty treatment program
(DE).
Frostbite (EI)
injuries of the hand have a wide variety early treatment recommendations,
but rapid rewarming is standard. Traditional management is observation
and delayed amputation (frost.htm). Bone
scan may help distinguish between unsalvageable and potentially salvageable
regions. Early operation may provide marginal tissue with a new blood supply
and preserve both function and length in the upper extremity.
Electrical injuries
of the the upper extremity may produce extensive deep tissue injury, compartment
syndrome, as well as delayed tissue necrosis and delayed vascular
thrombosis (EM) . Early exploration and
decompression of deep compartments, vascular graft reconstruction of segmental
defects and early free microvascular flap reconstruction reduce amputation
rate and shorten recovery (EK, EL,
DM,
EO)
. Even with optimum treatment, long term sensory loss is common
and remains and unsolved problem (EJ).
Degloving injuries of
the hand most often result from the hand being caught in moving machinery.
When possible, microvascular replantation of the degloved tissues probably
gives the best final result, although sensory recovery is difficult to
achieve even with this technique (CB).
If replantation is not possible, efforts to salvage a crushed avulsed flap
are usually unrewarding, and primary excision and resurfacing with a graft
or flap (crush.htm) is indicated to avoid
a prolonged course of progressive flap loss, delayed healing, infection
and stiffness.
Mangling hand injuries
result in a wide zone of mechanical injury, usually involving all tissue
components of the hand. Mechanisms include crush, blast, ballistic, traction
and avulsion injuries. All complications are possible, and these are at
particular risk for delayed healing, marginal wound necrosis (15050.htm),
infection (1434502x.htm), delayed thrombosis,
prolonged swelling, compartment syndrome (AS,
BB),
intrinsic muscle contractures (1505201.htm),
nonunion (gsw.htm, percmeta.htm),
stiffness, and lack of sensory recovery (CB).
The initial management plan is critical, as outlined in the next section.
Complications of treatment
of severe hand wounds add
additional trouble to an already difficult situation.
Failure to proceed
with primary amputation: It is a difficult decision to decide
when to attempt replantation of amputated digit or hand. It is even
more difficult and emotionally stressful to decide when to amputate a severely
injured hand or digit, particularly when the part in question has at least
the appearance of an existing blood supply. "Saving" a mangled hand
may simply burden the patient with a painful useless extremity, a triumph
of technique over judgment. One guide to making this decision is
to ask the question "If this extremity looked like this, but was a complete
amputation, would replantation be indicated?". If the answer is clearly
"no", primary amputation should be strongly considered (grisly.htm).
The best time to proceed with primary amputation for a mangled extremity
is the very first operation. If the surgeon realizes at the time of
the first operation that the hand is unsalvageable, but does not amputate,
it sets a precedent for false expectations and even greater disappointment
than would otherwise be endured. The patient in the family see the bandage,
conclude that the hand has been "saved", and will find it much more difficult
to accept the fact later that it has not. Although some patients with a
saved mangled extremity may decide later to have an elective hand amputation
(CK), most will be unable to make this
decision even if the hand is a burden and clearly inferior to a prosthesis.
Inadequate debridement:
The single common denominator of wound healing complications such as infection,
delayed healing, marginal necrosis, and wound breakdown is inadequate debridement.
If the zone of injury can be determined with reasonable certainty, severe
wounds should be radically debrided, anticipating the possible need for
complex flap closure. Debridement should remove severely contaminated
tissues and all ischemic tissues which cannot be vascularized. This includes
crushed flaps, distally based flaps with a length to width ratio greater
than one to two, and flaps which are obviously ischemic. Initial debridement
should be performed under tourniquet control, and proper initial debridement
of severe wounds involves en bloc tumor like excision using scalpel and
saw, not curette or irrigation, although these may be used later. The skin
of the palm has a primarily perpendicular rather than tangential vascular
pattern, and traumatic palmar flaps should be considered for primary excision
and alternate resurfacing, as their vascularity is quite unreliable (crush.htm).
Poor timing of wound closure:
Traditionally, the timing of closure of severe hand wounds has been classified
as primary (immediate), delayed primary (within two weeks), and secondary
(after two weeks). Historically, delayed primary closure was recommended
for military and other severe hand injuries. This recommendation is still
appropriate when the only available wound closure technique is direct closure
or closure with local flaps. However, the timing of wound closure
using distant or microvascular free flaps follows different guidelines.
The status of severe open wounds which are candidates for flap closure
is classified as acute (prior to the appearance of granulation tissue
- usually less than one week), subacute (after the appearance of
granulation tissue, before dense scarring - usually one to four weeks),
and chronic (usually after one month). Wounds which require flap
closure have the lowest complication rate (fewer flap failures,
fewer post-operative infections, shorter hospitalization, least number
of operations, shorter overall period of disability) when closure is performed
in the
acute phase and the highest complication
rate when performed during the
subacute phase (DC,
BD,
DK,
DL,
DN,
DO).
Free flap reconstruction of burn injuries has the lowest complication rate
when employed for the reexploration and reconstruction of healed, closed
burn injuries (DM).
Technical failure of complex
wound closure: Even with adequate debridement, avoidance of using local
flaps from potential zone of injury, and careful planning, wound closure
may fail. Skin grafts in the hand may be lost because of inability
to provide adequate immobilization, and flaps may be lost when the
complex wound dimensions exceed the capability of the flap. Although free
flaps tend to be successful or loss on an "all or none" basis, partial
free flap loss may occur. Pedicled flap loss usually occurs at the
exact point of critical need for flap coverage (flaploss.htm).
However, even a perfectly designed and executed flap cannot obviate the
effects of inadequate debridement or poor timing of wound closure.
Complications of replantation:
All
complications of complex hand wounds can occur following replantation,
including tendon adhesions, tendon rupture, neuroma, and delayed healing.
Replantation has additional risk for a number of other problems. Early
vascular failure (replant2.htm)
of replantation is influenced by mechanism of injury and patient selection.
Early failure is more common in smokers (CU),
more distal replantation level and in crush and avulsion injuries (DG).
Following successful revascularization, venous problems are more likely
to result in loss of replantation than arterial thrombosis (AQ,
AW).
The critical time for failure and for successful salvage is the first four
postoperative days (AW). Marginal
necrosis or interval gangrene (15050.htm),
as with other wounds is due to inadequate debridement or inability to distinguish
viable from nonviable tissues in a wide zone of injury. The most common
complication of a successful replant is stiffness due to tendon
adhesions (AQ). Cold intolerance
is uncommon following pediatric replantation, but occurs in most adult
replantations (AQ).
Aesthetically
disturbing fingertip atrophy occurs in nearly half of replanted
digits (AQ), due to the effects of incomplete
reinnervation and in some cases, late effects of prolonged ischemia (replant2.htm).
Lack
of sensory recovery is more common in adults than children, when both
arteries have not been repaired (CB),
and in avulsion injuries (DG). Local
vascular
complications such as pseudoaneurysm (AE),
arteriovenous fistula (BN), stricture,
and late thrombosis may occur as with any vascular repair. Delayed union,
nonunion, or avascular necrosis may occur, particularly when the replantation
is performed at the phalangeal neck level (BU),
because the phalangeal head is covered with cartilage, and has a primarily
intramedullary blood supply. Fractures or osteotomies through this level
are prone to this complication even out of the setting of replantation
(CM). Prolonged incapacitation
and multiple operations are typical, with the average patient requiring
two or more additional procedures after replantation (CC).
Judgment regarding indications for replantation must include consideration
that the poor results after replantation may be much disabling than primary
amputation. Functional outcome is significantly worse when replantation
involves prolonged ischemia (replant2.htm)
or injury in flexor tendon zone II (CU).
Complications of vascular
injuries
Missed vascular hand
injuries
Ring avulsion
injuries range from trivial skin lacerations to arterial or venous
disruption to combined injuries in continuity to complete amputation.
The zone of injury is usually greater than would be suspected from casual
inspection, and combined vascular and skeletal disruption injuries are
often not salvageable despite the external appearance of a simple laceration
(ringavul.htm). When the ring
is completely pulled off the finger in association with a circumferential
finger wound, the distal soft tissue envelope is usually severely injured,
effectively turning the soft tissue sleeve inside out and irreparably damaging
the distal part. For all but the most minor injuries, successful
salvage with vein grafts and flaps is unlikely, and even when successful,
often results in a stiff, insensate digit.
Partial vascular laceration
is the most likely mechanism for persistent uncontrolled hemorrhage, and
substantial bleeding may follow a partial venous laceration. As elsewhere,
persistent bleeding is better controlled by local pressure than blind clamping,
which may result in iatrogenic nerve injuries (clamp.htm).
Late effects include pseudoaneurysm, delayed hemorrhage and delayed thrombosis.
Iatrogenic vascular surgery
related hand complications
Graft harvest:
Radial artery harvest for coronary artery bypass may result in hand ischemia
or superficial radial nerve injury (AG,
BR).
The incidence of hand ischemia following radial artery harvest may be reduced
by the use of preoperative color duplex scanning in addition to care for
physical examination.
Dialysis access: Severe
hand ischemia occurs in nearly 2 percent of patients undergoing new angio
access surgery (AK). This problem is
more common in diabetic patients who have had multiple angio access procedures
(AI) or who have diabetic neuropathy
(BA) . Prompt recognition and treatment
is critical to avoid tissue loss and permanent nerve injury. This problem
should be suspected when finger pain, numbness or nerve symptoms arise
immediately after angio access surgery. Optimum treatment options
include ligation of the fistula, intraoperative duplex scanning guided
banding (AJ), or distal revascularization-interval
ligation. Neurologic symptoms may arise even if critical ischemia cannot
be demonstrated, and recovery of nerve function is unpredictable (BA).
Direct nerve compression may result from adjacent access materials (vascular.htm)
or hematoma around the side of a vascular suture line (BL).
Bypass surgery: Upper
extremity ischemia has been reported as a steal phenomena following axillofemoral
bypass graft, and due to emboli after thrombosis of an axillofemoral bypass
graft (BF, BQ).
General complications
of upper extremity vascular injuries: Ischemic gangrene, chronic ischemia,
intrinsic contractures, traumatic aneurysms, arteriovenous fistula, thrombosis
and embolism may occur in the hand as elsewhere following vascular
injury. Supracondylar fractures of the humerus may result in brachial artery
compression or disruption, and post ischemic reperfusion compartment syndrome
of the forearm can follow restoration of arterial flow following either
closed reduction or vascular repair. Fasciotomy should be considered if
ischemic time exceeds two hours, and should be performed if compartment
pressures are elevated.
Complications of treatment
of vascular injuries
Inappropriate
use of techniques to control bleeding in the emergency room can add
significant injury. Nearly all bleeding in the upper extremity can be controlled
by elevation and direct pressure. Tourniquet use in the emergency room
should be limited to a few minutes at most, and ideally only by the surgeon
who is going to provide the definitive surgical care. Inflating a tourniquet
and then waiting for the hand surgeon to arrive in the emergency room is
inappropriate, dangerous and limits future treatment options. Similarly,
use of local destructive intervention with clamps, ligature or cautery
(clamp.htm) by anyone other than the surgical
specialist assuming final care of the patient should be strongly discouraged.
Inappropriate primary
call to the vascular surgeon for upper extremity hemorrhage is a common
problem. Upper extremity hemorrhage is usually best managed by an upper
extremity surgeon. Time permitting, the ideal order of repair of the
severely injured upper extremity is debridement, skeletal stabilization,
musculotendinous repairs, nerve repairs, and then vascular repairs
(flow.htm), all under tourniquet control.
Such an approach minimizes hemorrhage and allows the most precise primary
repairs. Unfortunately, a common scenario is that the bleeding arm is first
managed by a vascular surgeon who does not provide definitive care of adjacent
nerve and musculoskeletal injuries. In this situation, the vascular
injury is repaired, often with a graft, and then the extremity surgeon
called in to complete the work. When the adjacent nerve and muscles
are then repaired, the vascular "gap" requiring a graft disappears, and
the graft may need to be removed to avoid kinking from redundancy. Similarly,
performing only vascular repair, closing the wound and referring to patient
for secondary repair of adjacent structure may sacrifice the best opportunity
to do a precise primary repair of all structures in the most safe and efficient
manner.
Complications of tendon
injuries
Missed tendon injuries
can occur when either the patient or the initial examining physician fails
to appreciate subtle findings.
Partial tendon
lacerations (partend.htm) should
be suspected when the patient has apparent full motion, but has pain
when attempting to use the tendon against resistance. Consequences
of partial tendon lacerations include delayed rupture, scarring
with tendon adhesions, triggering and weakness.
Missed finger extensor
mechanism injuries may occur because the broad expanse of the extensor
mechanism can initially maintain posture until softening from the healing
process allows the remnants of support to give way. Terminal tendon
injuries at the distal interphalangeal joint, and central slip injuries
at the proximal interphalangeal joint should be suspected when there is
a regional injury and pain with attempted extension against resistance,
even if the patient has a full active unresisted motion.
Missed finger flexor tendon
injuries are less common than missed extensor tendon injuries because
of change in the resting posture of the hand
(cuttend.htm).
Isolated superficialis
tendon injury with an intact profundus tendon produces a subtle change
in finger posture, and is easily missed. Profundus tendon avulsion
injuries (profavul.htm)
are
often unappreciated by the patient, who believes that the finger is simply
"jammed", and delays medical evaluation until the best window of opportunity
for treatment has passed. If there is significant proximal retraction after
profundus avulsion, the flexor tendon sheath fills with blood, and within
a matter of days shrinks enough that reinsertion is either impossible or
does not result in functional movement.
Missed dorsal hand extensor
tendon injuries may occur with little initial functional deficit, either
through action of adjacent tendinous junctures, or in the index or small
fingers if only one of two (proprius and communis) tendons has been cut.
Extensor
pollicis longus tendon injuries may be missed because of trick motion
through the action of the thumb intrinsic muscles on the thumb extensor
mechanism, which may allow interphalangeal joint extension to neutral despite
a divided extensor pollicis longus tendon.
Common complications
of tendon injuries of the hand include stiffness, contractures, tendon
rupture, recurrent adhesions and weakness, and depend on the exact level
of injury.
The worst results
of flexor tendon injuries occur in injuries located in the flexor
tendon sheath extending from the metacarpal head to the middle portion
of the middle phalanx - referred to as "zone II" or "no man's land". Even
under ideal management, only about half of injuries at this level recover
good to excellent function, and fewer have a satisfactory outcome following
staged flexor tendon reconstruction with a tendon graft (CJ).
Quadrigia
syndrome refers to limited excursion of the middle, ring, and small
fingers due to tethering connections between the profundus tendons of these
fingers. This may follow a simple flexor tendon injury or be due
to adhesions following amputation.
The worst results of extensor
tendon injuries occur when injuries are located over the dorsum of
the proximal phalanx or the proximal interphalangeal joint. Loss
of proximal interphalangeal joint motion may take the form of a fixed contracture,
swan neck deformity, or boutonniere finger. Thin soft tissue cover and
poor tolerance of any length change both contribute to poor results at
this level.
Complications of the treatment
of tendon injuries
Tendon adhesions
and are the most common problem following tendon repair. Rupture
of a flexor tendon repair occurs in at least four percent of patients following
primary flexor tendon repair in zone II with postoperative controlled passive
motion (CJ). Stiffness may be due to
either or both problems, and it may be impossible to determine the nature
of loss of motion, even with MRI.
Mallet finger: Nearly
half of patients treated for mallet finger develop some type of complication
of treatment. Complications following surgery are more common,
more serious (e.g. deep infection), and more frequently permanent than
those arising from splinting alone (BG).
Bowstringing due to
incompetence of the flexor tendon pulley system may follow injury or iatrogenic
injury during efforts to expose, retrieve, and repair the tendon.
External ring splints to support the tendon pulley system are commonly
used, but have not shown to be mechanically effective in preventing bowstringing.
Staged flexor tendon reconstruction
using temporary silastic tendon spacers followed by tendon grafts carry
all the risks of primary tendon repair. In addition, staged reconstruction
is more likely to result in flexion contractures, and greatly extend
the necessary length of incapacitation.
Complications of nerve
injuries
Missed nerve injuries
Partial nerve
lacerations may be missed because their presentation is not a full
blown picture of anesthesia or paralysis. Such injuries are best
treated by a primary repair (prtnerve2.htm).
Delayed or secondary exploration may result in additional nerve injury,
because it may be impossible to distinguish between healing tissue, scar
tissue, and nerve tissue which either functioning or has the capacity to
heal. Late exploration of a healed partial nerve injury usually reveals
an amorphous neuroma in continuity, and the only practical option may be
to completely divide the nerve, excise the entire neuroma and reconstruct
the entire nerve with nerve grafts. This may be difficult to justify when
the patient has either retained or recovered partial nerve function
Motor branch injuries
are most often missed following small entry deeply penetrating wounds.
The ulnar motor branch in the palm, the median motor branch in the palm,
and the posterior interosseous nerve in the forearm may be injured without
producing sensory loss and may be missed by casual survey.
Common complications of nerve
injuries in the hand as elsewhere include tender neuroma, paralysis,
and incomplete sensory recovery. In addition, upper extremity nerve
injuries usually produce some degree of cold intolerance, and are
a common trigger for complex regional pain syndrome. Dysesthesia
and disuse of the hand may occur, and are best treated with an aggressive
desensitization and sensory reeducation program under the supervision of
a hand therapist. Median nerve injuries result in a greater loss of hand
function than ulnar nerve injuries because the critical contact areas of
the hand are affected.
Complications of the treatment
of nerve injuries include failure due to repair under tension,
repair within a poorly vascularized soft tissue bed, and contractures
due to splinting to relieve tension on a tight repair. Patients who have
a wide zone of anesthesia must be instructed on self protection from cuts
and burns. Contractures from paralysis are avoidable, but must be anticipated
and prevented with splinting: untreated, median nerve palsy will result
in a first web space contracture, and ulnar nerve palsy will result
in proximal interphalangeal joint contractures of the ring and small fingers.
Complications of fractures
and joint injuries
Missed fractures and joint
injuries
Scaphoid
and hook of hamate fractures are commonly missed,
and are discussed below.
Reversed Bennett's fracture
is an intra-articular fracture of the base of the small finger metacarpal,
usually associated with dorsal and proximal subluxation of the metacarpal
shaft due to the unresisted action of the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon.
In contrast to intra-articular fractures of the thumb metacarpal base (Bennett's
and Rolando's fractures) which have a similar pathologic anatomy (bennett.htm)
and good outcome with a variety of treatment techniques (CP),
reversed Bennett's fractures are prone to chronic symptoms from posttraumatic
arthritis. These fractures are easily missed on plain anteroposterior and
lateral x-rays, and presentation is frequently delayed when they are sustained
in a boxing injury mechanism.
Phalangeal
neck fractures may go unrecognized despite rotation or dorsal translation
of the distal fracture fragments, because alignment may look deceptively
normal with routine posteroanterior x-rays. The rotated phalangeal neck
fracture is unstable, prone to nonunion (CM),
and is sometimes referred to as "hangman's fracture" (hangman.htm)
because it is easy to miss in children and difficult to treat late.
Missed ligament injuries
are usually missed because the patient downplays the extent of injury,
only to seek evaluation later because of persistent symptoms. The
most common missed ligament injuries are gamekeeper's
thumb and scapholunate ligament injuries,
both discussed below.
Complications of common fractures
and joint injuries
Intraarticular
fractures
of the fingers frequently result and stiffness and functional
impairment, particularly when sustained during childhood (BZ).
Displaced articular fractures should have anatomic reduction and fixation
whenever possible. Even minor degrees of malalignment are usually
unacceptable. Long term problems including degenerative arthritis
are common even with optimum initial care.
Pathologic fractures
in the hand are most commonly due to enchondroma involving one of the tubular
bones. Complications of treatment are more likely with immediate compared
to the delayed treatment of the tumor (AB),
and the preferred management of pathologic fracture through a benign and
tumor is to let the the fracture heal, then return for definitive treatment
of the tumor.
Phalangeal fracture
complications: Distal phalanx fractures carry all of the complications
previously discussed for fingertip injuries. Displaced
distal phalanx fractures (1121100s.htm)
may give rise to nonunion if not reduced and provided adequate internal
fixation. Phalangeal neck fractures are discussed above.
Phalangeal shaft fractures are affected to a much greater degree by
associated soft tissue damage and have an overall worse outcome than metacarpal
fractures of similar magnitude. Poor functional outcome is common
with phalangeal fractures which are open, comminuted, or
associated with either significant soft tissue injury or periosteal
stripping - including periosteal stripping performed during open reduction
(DX,
CG),
when there is associated nerve or tendon injury. Only about
one in six displaced phalangeal fractures are stable after closed reduction
(CG), and redisplacement may occur following
temporary Kirschner wire fixation. Angulation results in a zig zag posture
due to tendon in balance, resulting in joint contractors to a degree similar
to the degree of proximal angulation (0063106S.htm).
Outcome is not improved with the use of plate and screw fixation compared
to Kirschner wire fixation (CE). Based
on outcome studies, a strong argument can be made to refer all finger fractures
to
a surgeon with specialty training in hand surgery (CF).
Phalangeal joint injuries
prone to complications include essentially all interphalangeal joint
injuries, because the precision nature of the interphalangeal joints.
It is common for the sprained proximal interphalangeal joint to be stiff,
tender, painful and swollen for six to twelve months after injury.
Permanent joint enlargement and flexion contractures are common consequences
of even a minor sprain or "jammed finger". Mallet fracture dislocations
(mallet.htm) of the distal interphalangeal
joint should be distinguished from simple stable displaced mallet fractures,
because outcome following conservative management is poor due to joint
incongruity.
Pure dislocations of the proximal interphalangeal joint
(PIPDIS.htm) are most commonly dorsal,
usually stable after reduction, and carry about the same outlook has a
bad sprain of this joint. In contrast, palmar dislocations
or dislocations with a lateral component are frequently unstable
after reduction and are more prone to progressive contractures, angulation,
and degenerative joint changes. Fracture dislocations of the proximal
interphalangeal joint are usually dorsal with a small volar plate avulsion
fracture. These are usually stable if the volar fracture fragment comprises
less than one third of the articular surface. In contrast, dorsal
fracture dislocations in which the palmar fragment involves more than
one third of the joint surface, palmar fracture dislocations,
and combined dorsal and palmar fractures ("pilon fractures") are
intrinsically unstable, and have persistent subluxation (PIPFD.htm).
These extremely difficult injuries may require internal and external fixation,
cancellous or osteochondral grafting, and may be unsalvageable.
Metacarpal fractures prone
to complications: Metacarpal fractures have fairly predictable healing,
but nonunion is more likely in injuries sustained with a crush or blast
mechanism. Gunshot injuries of the fingers frequently result in
amputation, but similar injuries in the metacarpal area may produce surprisingly
little nerve and tendon damage despite severe skeletal injury and risk
of nonunion (gsw.htm). Multiple metacarpal
fractures are often sustained in crush injury, and the decision
must be made between the need for compartment decompression, wide exposure
for open reduction and internal fixation versus the use of percutaneous
fixation to minimize additional injury (percmeta.htm).
Metacarpal joint injuries
prone to complications: Complex dislocations are dislocations in which
intraarticular soft tissue interposition provides a block to reduction,
also referred to as irreducible dislocations. These most often involve
the metacarpophalangeal joints, the home most often involved, and are usually
associated with sesamoid interposition (1437308x.htm).
These must be recognized to avoid additional injury from overzealous attempts
at closed reduction, and usually require open reduction. Rupture
of the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint ulnar collateral ligament, also
known as ski pole thumb or gamekeeper's thumb occurs when
the thumb is forced into radial deviation. The extent of injury is
frequently not appreciated by the patient and delayed presentation is common.
Results of acute ligament repairs are better than those of late reconstruction
(CD), and arthrodesis may be indicated.
Carpal injuries prone
to complications
Scaphoid
fractures (scaphfx.htm) Scaphoid
fractures are prone to healing problems because of the combination of poor
perfusion of the proximal fracture fragment and strong forces across the
fracture site from normal wrist mechanics. Scaphoid fractures may
heal in malunion ("humpback deformity"), but delayed union and nonunion
are much more common and difficult problems. Left untreated, scaphoid nonunions
have a natural progression to a characteristic pattern of wrist arthritis,
initially involving the radioscaphoid and capitolunate joints, referred
to as scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse, or "SNAC wrist"
Unstable,
displaced,
or proximal fractures are prone to nonunion even with prolonged
casting, and should be considered for early open reduction, because the
outcome of surgery is more likely to be satisfactory for acute unstable
or displaced fractures than for unstable or displaced
nonunions.
Open reduction, bone graft and screw fixation has as high as a forty percent
failure for unstable or displaced nonunions (BW).
Scapholunate
ligament injuries occur from the same mechanism of injury as scaphoid
fractures. Like scaphoid fractures, these injuries may not be apparent
on initial x-rays. Dynamic scapholunate dissociation may be obvious
only on kinematic or stress deviation radiographs. Conversely, bilateral
benign congenital scapholunate diastasis may be confused with an
acute injury if both sides are not compared (0049102s.htm).
Left untreated, scapholunate dissociation has a natural progression to
a characteristic pattern of wrist arthritis, initially involving the radioscaphoid
and capitolunate joints, referred to as scapholunate advanced collapse,
or "SLAC wrist" (sldis.htm) (DW).
Treatment options include partial wrist fusion, proximal row carpectomy,
and a variety of soft tissue ligament reconstruction procedures. Capsulodesis
procedures appear to be more successful than tendon graft procedures, although
no current soft tissue procedure reliably corrects scapholunate diastasis
visible on x-ray (BY). Injuries associated
with scapholunate dissociation or in partial ligament disruption have a
better outcome following surgery than those resulting in complete disruption
with a static instability pattern (BY).
Perilunate dislocations
and fracture dislocations (lunatedis.htm,
plfd.htm)are
severe wrist injuries which usually result in some degree of permanent
wrist stiffness even with ideal management. These injuries may not
be appreciated on casual inspection, the most common report of inadequate
evaluation being "something just isn't right". These injuries require
open reduction and internal fixation and frequently require carpal tunnel
release for acute traumatic neuritis.
Hook
of hamate fractures are often difficult to demonstrate with plain Xrays,
and additional evaluation and management may be indicated based on clinical
suspicion (1113201xs.htm,
hook.htm).
Fractures of the hook of the hamate rarely heal with conservative treatment.
The problem may mimic a variety of other problems, including carpometacarpal
or capitohamate joint disorders. Problems with this fracture include flexor
tendon rupture from abrasion against the fractured hook area. Tendon
rupture is a significant complication, often resulting in permanent disability
despite multiple operations and extensive therapy. Surgery to remove the
fractured hook and inspect the tendons and nerves is indicated to minimize
these risks.
Forearm fractures prone
to complications:
Distal radius
fractures account for about one out of every six of fractures seen
in the emergency room and three out of four forearm fractures. They are
most common in both sexes between 6 and 10 years and in women between 60
and 69 years old. They may be classified by a number of schemes, but no
existing scheme correlates well with final functional outcome (CZ).
A large number of operative and nonoperative treatment options have been
recommended, many of which appear to give comparable results. Operative
treatments include external fixation, percutaneous pinning, open reduction,
and any combination of these. Poor final outcome is more likely
when the fracture is initially very displaced, when the distal
radioulnar joint is involved, when the radiocarpal joint is comminuted,
when there is residual shortening greater than 2 mm or dorsal
angulation
greater than 15 degrees. Closed reduction of intra-articular distal radius
fractures has a satisfactory outcome in about four out of five cases (BX).
However, about one out of three closed reductions redisplace, and
only one out of three of fractures which redisplace and require repeated
closed manipulation have a good or excellent final outcome (BX).
There are conflicting reports regarding the importance of final fracture
alignment on function, but one can make the argument to avoid malunion
(radmalun.htm) because secondary surgery
for distal radius malunion is successful in only three out of four patients
(CX). Nonunion (rnonunion.htm,
1441107x.htm)
is uncommon, but is more likely following severely displaced fractures
because of the possibility of pronator quadratus or other soft tissue interposition.
Complex
regional pain syndrome (rsd.htm) and
finger stiffness occur to some degree in as many as one out of three patients.
Loss
of motion is also common, but unpredictable. Tendon rupture
(AV), early or late, open or closed,
relating to fracture displacement, hardware irritation (1441107x.htm)
(AP) or ulnar head prominence.
Median
or ulnar nerve compression may develop early or late following this
fracture. Posttraumatic arthritis is most common in young
adults, seen in radiographs of two out of three young patients evaluated
years after injury. Fortunately, radiographs do not correlate well with
the degree of symptoms, and many of these patients are asymptomatic. Compartment
syndrome of the forearm may develop in association with emergency reduction
and stabilization of a distal radius fracture with a circumferential cast.
However, compartment syndrome of the forearm may develop after high energy
injury distal radius fracture even in the absence of circumferential cast
or bandages (BC), and may develop up
to 48 hours after the initial injury (AZ).
Distal radius fractures in males under 50 years old are at particular risk
(BH), probably because these represent
a subset of high energy injuries. If clinical examination is unreliable,
as in patients who are obtunded or whose symptoms may be masked by narcotics,
in hospital observation and or repeated measurement of compartment pressures
may be indicated during the first two days after injury. Carpal instability
may develop, either as a discrete ligament injury or as a result of changes
in the radiocarpal joint angle. Nonunion of associated ulnar styloid fractures
is common and usually painless. Prolonged recovery (six to twelve
months) is typical, as are long term subjective symptoms, such as pain,
fatigue, and loss of grip strength. Such symptoms are reported by about
half of patients with a non-compensation related injury; in about four
out of five adult patients under the age of 45, and in essentially all
patients with compensation related injury. Despite this, three out of four
patients on the average have a satisfactory functional result following
distal radius fracture.
Both bone forearm fractures
in an adult may result in a variety of problems. Complications are more
common and prognosis is worse for displaced fractures and for open
fractures. On the average, nondisplaced fractures take six to eight weeks
to heal, and displaced fractures take three to five months. Satisfactory
functional end results may be expected in about eight out of ten patients
with nondisplaced fractures and about one half of those with displaced
fractures. As many as one half of patients will have obvious loss of forearm
pronation, which may or may not be functionally significant. Loss of forearm
rotation is most likely when fractures occur in the middle third of the
forearm. Synostosis may lock the forearm in a fixed position of
rotation. Nonunion occurs in as many as one out of ten patients
(1360603x.htm). Nonunion related to
technique is more likely when semitubular plates are used, or when less
than six cortices are engaged on each side of the fracture. Early protected
motion appears to improve the odds of satisfactory final motion. Internal
or external fixation is usually indicated for open or very unstable fractures,
accepting the risk that postsurgical infection may occur in as many as
one out of twenty patients. Proximal forearm fractures are associated
with a variety of problems, including nonunion, nerve and tendon injuries
and synostosis. One fifth to one half of patients can be expected to have
significant permanent loss of forearm rotation. Open treatment of acute
fracture or nonunion may be complicated by additional nerve injury or synostosis,
more likely when injuries are open or classified as high energy. Synostosis,
or cross union between the radius and ulna is much more common in proximal
than in distal forearm fractures, occurring in about one out of fifteen
patients with proximal fractures. Synostosis is more likely in children,
with open fractures, with single incision access to both forearm bones,
and following high energy injuries. Results of surgery for correction of
synostosis are poor when surgery is performed less than one year or more
than three years after injury, and even under ideal conditions, only one
in five patients can be expected to regain as much as 50 degrees of forearm
rotation.
Longitudinal forearm fracture
dislocations (1185902.htm) include
three special combinations of injury: Galeazzi fracture-dislocation, Monteggia
fracture-dislocation, and the Essex-Lopresti lesion (CC).
Galeazzi
fracture-dislocation refers to a fracture of the shaft of the radius associated
with dislocation of the distal radioulnar joint.
Monteggia fracture-dislocation
refers to fracture of the ulna with dislocation of the radial head. Each
of these fracture-dislocation patterns is best treated with open fracture
reduction and closed treatment of the dislocation. Essex-Lopresti lesion
refers to longitudinal disruption of the radioulnar interosseous membrane
and proximal migration of the radius associated with fractures involving
the proximal radioulnar joint, the distal radioulnar joint, or both sites.
The most common presentation of Essex-Lopresti is associated with radial
head excision for fracture, resulting in ulnocarpal impingement syndrome.
Treatment is controversial. When diagnosed acutely in the context of an
unreconstructable radial head fracture, Essex-Lopresti justifies use of
a temporary radial head implant. Late surgical options include ulnar shortening
osteotomy or the developing technique of ligament reconstruction with a
tendon graft.
Radial head fractures
often appear to be an isolated injury, but are associated with distal radial
ulnar joint pathology due to proximal migration of the radius as well as
elbow arthritis and loss of elbow motion. Early excision of radial head
fractures has a significant complication rate, including proximal migration
of the radius, which occurs to some degree in the majority of patients
(AC). Efforts should be made to reconstruct
rather than excise a fractured radial head.
Skeletally immature forearm
fractures and dislocations: "Isolated" radial head fractures in children
are often associated with some degree of plastic deformation of the ulna,
or "plastic" Monteggia fracture. Chronic pediatric radial head dislocation
associated with plastic deformation of the ulna is frequently unrecognized,
and requires open reduction and ulna osteotomy in late cases (DA).
Complications of the treatment
of fractures and joint injuries have been covered in the previous sections.
The most common of these are
nonunion (1360603x.htm,
gsw.htm,
exfixx.htm),
external
fixation related infection or fracture (exfixx.htm),
arthrofibrosis
and capsuloligamentous contractures, osteomyelitis (osteo.htm),
tendon
adhesions or rupture (1441107x.htm),
hardware
prominence, exposure, or related fracture (1484602s.htm,
stressr.htm),
and complex regional pain syndrome (rsd.htm)
Complications of infection:
Infections
are always considered a complication, and have common presentations in
the hand.
Missed diagnosis of infection:
Herpetic whitlow, a viral skin infection of the finger pulp, is commonly
misdiagnosed as an abscess, felon or paronychia. Diagnosis is suggested
by a prodrome of pain, and early signs of tiny vesicles and itching.
Incision and drainage only prolongs recovery and should be avoided if possible.
Missed
deep infections (ctpus.htm) of the
hand are possible because the dense fibrous compartments within the hand
mask swelling and contour changes from deep abscess. Diagnosis is
made based on suspicion, with the caveat that throbbing hand pain which
keeps the patient awake at night associated with any other signs of
infection indicating deep hand abscess until proven otherwise.
Missed
severe contamination has been discussed in the previous
section on complications of missed complex wounds.
Complications of infections
and
infections prone to complications: Unsatisfactory results are more
likely when hand infections involve anaerobes, Eikenella corrodens or human
bites (CH). Quantitative cultures
are the single most sensitive and specific predictor of infection following
microvascular free flap reconstruction of complex extremity injuries, and
should be a routine part of this form of treatment. Complex wounds which
are found to have greater than 1000 organisms per cubic centimeter at the
time of free flap closure should be treated with return to the operating
room, flap elevation, repeated debridement and closure (DJ).
Atypical infections (CH) may involve
subcutaneous tissues or more commonly tendon sheath spaces. Mycobacteria
species, most commonly mycobacterium marinum produce slowly progressive
hand infections. Deep space infections from either typical or atypical
infection usually follow puncture wounds contaminating tendon sheath compartments
or joint spaces. The most vulnerable areas where apparently trivial wounds
can contaminate deep spaces are the flexion greases of the fingers and
the extension creases on the dorsum of the fingers. Diabetic hand infections,
particularly in patients with diabetic chronic renal failure, are common,
frequently severe and often result in tissue loss. Hand infections in such
patients are frequently more severe than they appear by clinical examination,
and the surgeon must have a low threshold for early extensile surgical
debridement of the entire zone of inflammation (CA).
Gram negative infections are common, and amputation is a common consequence.
Pyarthrosis
and septic arthritis of the small joints of the hand is more likely to
achieve a poor results if presenting after ten days from injury, or when
associated with severe trauma (DB).
The most common scenario for small joint infection of the hand involves
clenched fist bite injury (boxer4.htm).
Hematogenous
seeding resulting in implant infection (1400001S.htm,
1351400s.htm)
is an uncommon but catastrophic problem justifying prophylactic antibiotics
during high risk procedures for patients who have implants such as silastic
joint spacers which maintain a permanent open space around the implants.
Tetanus may develop following hand injuries (BO),
and is most common in the context of parenteral drug abuse. More commonly,
deep soft tissue infections from parenteral drug abuse are polymicrobial,
and may present as gas forming infection (ivdagas.htm),
necrotizing infection, or suppurative thrombophlebitis
(BP). Treatment requires excision of
the involved area, wide drainage, repeated debridement, and appropriate
parenteral antibiotics.
 |
American Society for Surgery of the Hand assh.org
The Best Resource For Your Hands, Period.
|